Plagiarising Science Fraud

Plagiarising Science Fraud
Newly Discovered Facts, Published in Peer Reviewed Science Journals, Mean Charles Darwin is a 100 Per Cent Proven Lying, Plagiarising Science Fraudster by Glory Theft of Patrick Matthew's Prior-Published Conception of the Hypothesis of Macro Evolution by Natural Selection

Sunday 18 December 2022

The English Politics of the Suppression of the Scot Patrick Matthew

The English "Establishment" of Charles Darwin's landed gentry nasty pals played no small part in the suppression of the truth about who originated the theory Darwin stole. See the relevant facts on PatrickMatthew.Com : Here

Saturday 12 November 2022

The Patrick Matthew Violin

 In 2023 the Patrick Mathew Scottish heritage violin will be completed. 

This instrument is being made by a famous master violin maker, whose instruments are played by leading soloists and approved as "as good as my Petrus Guarneri" by Nigel Kennedy. 

The Patrick Matthew instrument has been specially commissioned by Dr Mike Sutton to celebrate the great Scottish Enlightenment science hero and original author of the theory Darwin and Wallace stole with the help of Darwin's powerful pals.  

Halloween 2022, when pressed by the journalist Sonia Poulton, Mike talks a little about this project for the very first time.

 In 2023 Scotland, and the world will be hearing a lot more from The Patrick Matthew violin.

The October 31 2022 news show clip of Mike talking with Sonia Poulton and Sean Ward about the notion of "haunted" violins and about the special commissioning of  The Patrick Matthew Scottish heritage violin is below.

The video of professional performance violinist Ursula Donnelley playing the "Haunted Tobin" violin is in the video below:

More about the Tobin Violin, which is for sale, here

The current "for sale" price of  The Tobin violin is here

Thursday 6 October 2022

Undeclared Commercial Conflict of Interest? Lunatic J F (Julian) Derry the Darwin Monkey Monger and Youth Hostel Toilets Cleaner

 If in any doubt that J F Derry is a psychopathic idiot in need of a padded cell and straight jacket for his own good click here to read his mad malicious and delusional obsessive childish idiocy. The poor deranged twerp. 

Julian Derry who, according to Linked-in, merely works as some kind of  youth hostel cleaner, appears to have a mental disorder that certainly involves a lot of complete weird projection of his own transparent inadequacies and malicious jealous behaviour onto others.  But when beloved old paradigms are overturned with new data we know such excellent yet shocking discoveries bring the sad and lonely nutters out of their mother's basements, and filthy little youth hostels, and onto the Internet. The "Fierce Resistance" stage in Kuhn's paradigm change cycle explains it (see Sutton 2022 for more examples and a deeper explanation).

Here we see a typical example (
Derry [Archived] on Twitter), in the image directly below of no doubt his own visits to his own stalker blog site that he has retweeted from another of his Twitter account. Real academics and journalists - particularly criminologists and psychologists - will no doubt cite this kind of thing in future case studies of such poor deranged creatures.

Besides cleaning a youth hostel for a living, Dr Julian (J.F. ) Derry is the nasty anal rape tweeting harassing and obsessively jealous, malicious and obscene, criminal stalker nut job (here) who owns and runs and profits financially from the commercial "Darwin Monkey" (see proof its him )  business - selling Darwin Industry paraphernalia models / ornaments -  is publishing academic papers on Charles Darwin and so is surely (isn't he?) wrongly declaring no conflict of interest: e.g a most recent Royal Society paper

Surely that is against the rules? Isn't it? Surely he is then, on his own silly little stalker website, projecting his own academic misconduct onto others who have not committed any academic misconduct - other than using empirical data to upset jealous academic failure nut cases like Derry and others blindly facilitating the Darwin Supermyth in the deluded hope they can somehow magically bury the hateful newly unearthed empirical data evidenced facts that bust it.

Here is as good a definition of what constitutes a commercial conflict of interest when it comes to academic papers as any: 

"A conflict of interest is a financial, intellectual relationship, personally owned and operated commercial business, or other  circumstances, that might affect, or reasonably be perceived by others to affect, an author’s judgement, conduct, or manuscript. When in doubt, disclose.More Here

Derry is criminally harassing Professor Mark Griffiths simply because Mark has supported the veracity of the new data that proves other naturalists did read (because it is newly found they cited it) Matthew's 1831 book containing the theory of evolution by natural selection before Darwin and Wallace replicated it. Deranged Derry criminally harasses anyone who does so. Here he is at it again. Totally insane obsessed, deluded nonsense as usual He needs serious psychiatric help. Obviously. How long before this total obsessive stalker loon harms someone? 

How many other academic papers about Darwin, or at least once mentioning Darwin, has Julian Derry done his failure to disclose act on? The telling question is this: What would the journal editors do if they found out what he is up to? How can his articles be objective when he has an undeclared commercial business interest in selling Darwin ornaments that glorify Darwin? Should his Darwin superfan papers now be retracted? Some cases like this lead to exactly that outcome. See:

Saturday 3 September 2022

Jerry Coyne - AKA God's Own Pseudo Scholar for Jesus"

 (Q) "What kind of scholar writes a load of desperate delusional speculative disinformation conspiracy theory claptrap about a book they admit have never read?"

(A) "A pseudo-scholar."

Ladies and Gentlemen and everyone else. I give you the anti-intellectual dosser Jerry Coyne ha ha ha and his credulous bunch of dosser trolls: . He even mistakes a witty satirical review of "Science Fraud as a serious review. What a total twit.😆 So typical of the Darwin Worship cult.

Sunday 17 July 2022

Dr Julian Derry and his pal Dr Joachim Dagg and their malicious activities are all recorded in a legal dossier that is now circulating


In an earlier blog post the empirical data proving the recent admission by Joachim Dagg that he maliciously plagiarised Dr Mike Sutton's original research data is revealed (here).

Dr Joachim Dagg who writes in his online profiles that he is a teacher and member of the Ronin institute has been publishing weirdly obsessive malicious falsehoods, mischievous misrepresentations and complete biased fact denial rhetoric about Dr Sutton's research for years. Why? Because in 2014 Dr Mike Sutton uncovered empirical data that proves, contrary to the old myth that nobody read his 1831 book and the theory of the natural process of selection in it until after Darwin and Wallace replicated it in 1858/59, that more than 30 people did cite Matthew's book before 1858 and that several of them were known and admitted major influencers of Darwin and Wallace. 

Ever since Sutton's 2014 bombshell research and the method used to find it has been published in books, book chapters and peer reviewed academic articles "Desperate Dagg" and his even more  desperate pal Dr Julian Derry have been maliciously misrepresenting Dr Sutton's original research in an attempt to rescue Darwin from what one rationally anonymous USA professor wrote today in an Amazon (verified purchase) book review: 

'Sutton also documented that the Darwin Industry has worked hard to re-bury the newly unearthed facts that Sutton uncovered by fact-denial and censorship. Darwin’s status has now taken a major hit and may be the start of his fall.' (The Professor 2022).

"The Professor" has written 459 Amazon reviews.

"The Professor's" profile on reads: 

"I am a college professor and author of numerous books, now in 14 languages. I also speak widely in the U.S. and several foreign countries. I am also very active in Jewish affairs."

In addition to Dagg running a ludicrous childish blogsite based on the psychology inside his own head, rather than actual physical reality, his friend Derry has an arguably even more ludicrous malicious one that actually has Dr Sutton's name as its title (typical page archived here)

Dr Julian Derry, when not falsely pretending to be affiliated with Edinburgh University,  describes himself to academic journals as an independent academic. In fact he owns a tatty Darwin Industry paraphernalia business called "Darwin Monkey" where he is is falsely claiming to be a visiting scientist at Edinburgh University (see here) in order to sell his silly cheap Darwinite ornaments to the gullible. 

Archived proof  Dr Julian (AKA J.F. Derry) Derry is a Darwin Industry paraphernalia selling business owner:

How do we know the serial harasser, serial liar, "anal rape threatening tweeter" and obsessed malicious stalker Dr Julian Derry is not affiliated to Edinburgh University? That one is so easy. It is because he let slip he has been fired from the University for maliciously constantly harassing members of the Carse of Gowrie Sustainability Group and others involved with funding and building the Patrick Matthew Trail in Scotland with National Lottery Heritage funding in the wake of Dr Mike Sutton's (2014) bombshell research breakthrough that has tipped Derry clean over the edge. The proof is here. Typed with Derry's own hands. 

Derry is currently insinuating that Dr Sutton had his own (Sutton's) Twitter accounts suspended for any one or more nastily nefarious reasons (here).

In reality, Dr Sutton has had only two twitter accounts suspended by Twitter. The account Dysology was suspended merely because it is owned by Dr Sutton. Dysology was automatically suspended after Dr Sutton's Criminotweet account mocked both Boris Johnson and Donald trump by way of calling them each a "total retard" for their obnoxious and stupidly serial lying dishonest character flaws.

So Dr Sutton was "cancel cultured" by Twitter bots for using a word to describe such things as the ignition timing on a motor vehicle being - yes wait for it..."retarded". 

Now, of course, Dr Sutton was not writing about ignition timing. He meant that both Johnson and Trump are "backward". But today it is no longer acceptable to use such terminology to describe idiot twits and utter pillock harmful serial liars as "retarded" or "backward" even when you are doing so to punch upward against heads of state - both of whom have been kicked out of office (Boris) and voted from office (Trump) for serially disgracing themsleves with proven serial lies, racism and various other dishonest utter nonsense.

 Dr Sutton has never sought to appeal his Twitter ban. Why not? Because he thinks he probably did deserve it for writing the word "retarded".

 That said, others may disagree. But Sutton was most certainly not cancelled from Twitter for the nonsense listed in the image above by the malicious serial liar, jealous and totally obsessed mischievous  misrepresenter of facts, tacky brass monkey monger and laughably apparent desperate wannabe but totally failed in the attempt pseudo-criminologist Dr Julian - Desperate - Derry. Because, at least according to his own Amazon author page, the year before Dr Mike Sutton first published his bombshell research findings on Darwin and Richard Dawkins and Patrick Matthew on the Best Thinking blogsite, 

J F Derry wrote a rubbish gutter trash book in 2012 entitled "serial killers". Today it can be bought for a mere 40p on eBay. According to Amazon this is Julian Derry, He appears to be a delusional wannabe criminologist, but has failed miserably at it. Of course he has.

In 2022, Dr Sutton has been asked to provide others with a forensic archive dossier file containing the harassment activities (including poison pen malicious emails)  written by Derry, Dagg and their other associate, Dr Mike Weale. This dossier is now circulating and being officially assessed for several serious pending actions. 

"The Professor" who only today published his honest five star review of Sutton's latest book "Science fraud" and noted that the Darwin Industry is working hard to re-bury the facts Sutton originally unearthed on Darwin and Wallace may well be reading the Dagg and Derry Dossier right now. Others certainly are. Facts always burrow to the top in the end.  


                                                                            By Anon. 17.07.2022

                                                                            This is an archived blog post

Monday 11 July 2022

Pitfalls of Plagiarism: The Case Study of Joachim Dagg AKA "Dagg The Plagiarist"

An important finding from my original research data on who cited Patrick Matthew's 1831 book "On Naval Timber and Arboriculture" before 1858 has been plagiarised by Joachim Dagg. 

The story of Dagg's research plagiarism in the Biological Journal of the Linnean Society is told on a couple of pages of my latest book (Sutton 2022) "Science Fraud", which is published by Curtis Press, and is available directly from the publisher (here).

 My book's full title is: "Science Fraud: Darwin's Plagiarism of Patrick Matthew's Theory". It can be ordered from any good bookshop, many online bookstores and is available on Amazon UK (here), elsewhere throughout all Amazon sites in Europe and most recently in the USA (here).

Dagg's Confession is now Published in the Public Domain

Last night Dagg let it slip that he is "rationalising" his plagiarism of my data. 

Such guilt neutralisation rationalisation is a well know pitfall leading people to commit acts of plagiarism (e.g. here) In his desperate haste to seek to rationalize his malicious plagiary, Dagg writes 1942. of course, the real date of Selby's newly discovered citation of Matthew's (1831) book is 1842. 

There is a page dedicated to the repeat plagiarism of  Dr Mike Sutton's original, prior published, research data on PatrickMatthew.Com. The specific page is here

Dagg's accidental confession is forensically archived here 

This blog post is archived here for easier citation and for posterity.

Sunday 3 July 2022

Monday 20 June 2022

Book Reviews of Science Fraud

Book Reviews of "Science Fraud: Darwin's Plagiarism of Patrick Matthew's Theory"

Review by Ton Munnich "More evidence from Suttonon Goodreads (archived here) and Amazon Netherlands (archived here

Review by David Parkin "We may have to rethink our preconceptions about Darwin and his work" on Amazon (archived here)  

Review by HBK (AKA Ian Hardie) "Darwin - the case for plagarism of Patrick Matthew's Theory of Natuaral Selection" On Amazon (archived here) On Goodreads (here) (archived here)

Review by Catherine Philips "A fascinating read" On Amazon (archived here) On Goodreads (archived here)

Review by Leon McNair (AKA The Kilted Scotsman) on Goodreads (here) Archived (here)

Sunday 29 May 2022

American Scientists and Journalists Wanted by Curtis Press

 On June 15 2022 Curtis Press release my new book "Science Fraud: Darwin's plagiarism of Patrick Matthew's theory" in the USA.

Scientists and Journalists in the USA can request a free review copy of Science fraud from Curtis Press.

Curtis Press knows that my book must reach a critical mass of readership for the independently verifiable facts that are in it to be accepted and for the current Victorian myth of Darwin's supposed original honest, unique genius originality, to be busted by veracity. Therefore the publisher is now inviting American scientists and journalists to get in touch in order to receive a complimentary review copy of the book that changes everything you once thought you knew about Charles Darwin.

"Science Fraud" has already attracted considerable attention in the press in the UK and elsewhere in Europe following it's release in this region earlier in 2022.

1. The Mail on Sunday (Feb 2022) (archivedIn Press Reader (archived)  

2. Sputnick (Feb 2022) (archived)

3. The Scottish Sun (Feb 2022) (archived)

4. The Times (Feb 2022) (archived in fulland here

5. The Courier (Feb 2022) (archived) (pdf)

6. The Daily Squib (Mar 2022) (archived)

7. Sunday Express (Mar 2022) 

8. Sunday Express serialized 1 (13 Mar 2022)

9. Sunday Express serialized 2 (20 Mar 2022)

10. Sunday Express serialised 3 (27 Mar 2022)

11. Sunday Express serialised 4 (3 Apr 2022)

12. The Courier (April 30 2022) (archived)

Visit the Patrick Matthew website for a wealth of fully evidenced empirical data in the story of Charles Darwin, Patrick Matthew and Alfred Wallace. Here.

Science fraud is available to order from all online or other bookshops. Available from Curtis Press (Here) and on Amazon (Here

Saturday 28 May 2022

Science Fraud bombshell book hits the USA in June 2022

 If you live in the USA and are a science reporter or science reviewer and would like a complimentary copy for review purposes please make contact with the publisher Curtis Press - LinkedIn reviewer shout-out Here from Neil Shuttleworth of Curtis Press. Or visit the Curtis Press website to request a free review copy: 

#patrickmatthew #curtispress #sciencefraud

Friday 27 May 2022

Dr Mike Sutton's Academic Influence

 What a difference a science book makes. I am now, according to one major algorithm (give or take three hundred or so) the 31,000th most influential person on planet Earth - of all time.

 Here: (archived here:

In 2013/14, I made the history of science and criminological discovery of a lifetime. That bombshell discovery was made with the BigData IDD method (Sutton and Griffiths 2018). Today, you can read about it in my latest book: "Science Fraud: Darwin's plagiarism of Patrick Matthew's theory" (Curtis Press) Here: Amazon books or direct from the science publisher Curtis Press: here

It has been said that when history deals you a card it outlines your destiny

History dealt me a card  back in 2013 when I first used Big Data analysis to originally and uniquely prove, contrary to what we have all been told we must believe, that Patrick Matthew's (1831) bombshell breakthrough of the origination of the theory of macroevolution by the natural process of selection in fact was read by other naturalists before Darwin and Wallace (in 1858) and Darwin (1859) replicated it and then called it their own theory. Moreover, those naturalists who I discovered did read and then cite Matthew's 1832 book in the published literature record were acknowledged influencers of Darwin and Wallace and of their influencer's influencers and all cited Matthew's book before 1858.

 Today I have it in my head that the world's greatest science fraud by plagiary and Charles Darwin are one and the same thing. My latest book (Sutton 2022) proves me right. 

History is on my side only because the newly unearthed and irrefutable empirical facts are on my side. Ultimately, the side of truth and veracity will always conquer the side of myths, lies and propaganda. 

Covered extensively in the press in 2022

1. The Mail on Sunday (Feb 2022) (archived)

In Press Reader  (archived)  

2. Sputnick (Feb 2022) (archived)

3. The Scottish Sun (Feb 2022) (archived)

4. The Times (Feb 2022) (archived in full)

and here

5. The Courier (Feb 2022) (archived) (pdf)

6. The Daily Squib (Mar 2022) (archived)

7. Sunday Express (Mar 2022) 

8. Sunday Express serialized 1 (13 Mar 2022)

9. Sunday Express serialized 2 (20 Mar 2022)

10. Sunday Express serialised 3 (27 Mar 2022)

11. Sunday Express serialised 4 (3 Apr 2022)

12. The Courier (April 30 2022) (archived)